Bank lending did not fall 5.7 percent in October, because the comparison switched from gross to net advances
The reported drop from Rs15.38 trillion to Rs14.51 trillion sets last month's gross figure against this month's net one. Like for like, advances rose 0.3 percent and the advances to deposits ratio went up, not down.

Pakistan's banks did not shrink their loan books by Rs870 billion in October. The reported figure, a fall of 5.7 percent from Rs15.38 trillion to Rs14.51 trillion, sets September's advances before provisions against October's advances after provisions. Measured the same way both months, lending rose 0.3 percent, and the advances to deposits ratio, reported as sliding from 37.7 percent to 36.1 percent, rose from 37.7 percent to 38.4 percent.
The record for October is the State Bank's weekly statement of position for all scheduled banks, as at close of business on 30 October. It shows deposits of Rs40.15 trillion, investments of Rs40.61 trillion and borrowings of Rs16.53 trillion. It also shows advances twice. Gross advances were Rs15.42 trillion. After provisions of Rs913 billion they were Rs14.51 trillion, which is the reported October number.
Reading the earlier months
The reported August advances of Rs14.5 trillion and September advances of Rs15.38 trillion match the gross series. Weekly gross advances were Rs14.33 trillion on 21 August and Rs14.37 trillion on 28 August, then Rs14.78 trillion on 18 September, Rs15.01 trillion on 25 September and Rs15.18 trillion on 2 October. Advances after provisions ran about Rs0.9 trillion lower on the same dates: Rs13.42 trillion, Rs13.47 trillion, Rs13.87 trillion, Rs14.09 trillion and Rs14.26 trillion. A net figure of Rs14.5 trillion in August would have sat about Rs1 trillion above anything in the weekly net series. The State Bank's monthly statement for 31 July shows the same gap: gross advances of Rs14.46 trillion, provisions of Rs904 billion and net advances of Rs13.56 trillion.
So the run reads gross in August, gross in September and net in October. The rise through September is real: weekly gross advances climbed 4.4 percent from 28 August to 25 September. The fall in October is the switch. Provisions of Rs912.8 billion are 5.9 percent of gross advances of Rs15,419 billion, close to the 5.7 percent drop. The sum can be redone from the statement: 15,418,951 less 912,780 leaves 14,506,171, in Rs million. This reading rests on the weekly statements and the July monthly statement, because the monthly statements for August to October were not available to check.
Provisions are money a bank sets aside against loans that may not be repaid, and the balance sheet deducts them from the loan book. That is why the statement carries two totals, and why a series that moves from one to the other shifts by the size of the provisions.
On a gross basis, advances rose from Rs15.38 trillion at the end of September to Rs15.42 trillion at the end of October, an increase of 0.3 percent. The weekly statement for 6 November shows gross advances of Rs15.37 trillion, 0.3 percent below the 30 October level. Weekly net advances for the five Fridays from 2 October to 30 October ran between Rs14.22 trillion and Rs14.51 trillion. None of these series shows a collapse.
A ratio that rose
The same mismatch moves the advances to deposits ratio. On gross advances, October's ratio is 38.4 percent (15,419 divided by 40,151). On net advances it is 36.1 percent. The September ratio of 37.7 percent is the gross version, so the like for like change is a rise of 0.7 percentage points, not a fall of 1.6.
Deposits add noise at a quarter end. The weekly statement of 25 September shows Rs39.05 trillion, while the 30 September figure was Rs40.83 trillion, a jump of Rs1.78 trillion in five days. By 30 October deposits were Rs40.15 trillion, and on 6 November they were back at Rs39.05 trillion, which puts the gross ratio at 39.4 percent. Comparing a quarter end figure with a mid quarter one will tend to show deposits falling.
The balance sheet says more than the monthly change. For every Rs100 of deposits on 30 October, banks held Rs101 of investments and Rs36 of net advances, and had borrowed Rs41. Investments exceeded deposits by Rs459 billion. Securities carry far less credit risk than loans, so banks hold a larger share of their funding in government and other paper than in lending to businesses and households. The statement does not split advances by borrower, so it cannot show how much of the Rs15.42 trillion went to the private sector.
For borrowers, a 5.7 percent fall in lending would have signalled tighter credit, and the weekly data shows none. For anyone tracking the ratio, it is comparable from month to month only if gross or net is held fixed. When the State Bank's November figures arrive, a net basis will read near 36 percent and a gross basis near 39 percent, so the basis has to be checked before any trend is read into it.





